• Home
  • Solutions
  • Industries
    • Propane
    • Jewelers
    • Enterprise & B2B
    • Printing
    • Healthcare
    • Newspaper & Media
    • Ecommerce & Retail
  • Software Companies
    • Partner Portal Login
  • Developers
  • Merchants
  • Insights
    • Blog
    • Integrated Payment Systems: The Ultimate Guide for Merchants
  • About
    • About Us
    • Testimonials
  • Contact
Contact Us

Home » Blog » Credit Card Surcharge: A Guide for Merchants and ISVs

Credit Card Surcharge: A Guide for Merchants and ISVs

  • June 20, 2025

Introduction: Why Surcharging Is Gaining Attention

Swipe, dip, tap—every time a customer pay(s) by credit card, the bill for processing fees comes to you. Those pennies-on-the-dollar add up fast, and recent card-network hikes have only raised the tab. Instead of blanket price increases, many businesses are exploring a credit card surcharge, a small, transparent additional fee that recovers costs without penalizing cash buyers. ISVs feel the pressure too: if merchants can’t protect their margins, they churn.

What Is a Credit Card Surcharge and How Does It Work?

A card surcharge is a percentage (capped at 3% by the major brands) added only to a credit card transaction. Debit and prepaid cards? Off-limits: card rules prohibit merchants from touching them. Cash and checks? Still the cash price with no fee. That’s why surcharging is not the same as a cash discount (where you show the higher card price first, then knock off a discount for cash).

Key guardrails: Make sure to check with your acquirer and the credit card brand for the most current rules and regulations.

  • Register with your acquirer and networks 30 days in advance.
  • Post signage at the entrance and point-of-sale.
  • Show the surcharge as its own line on the receipt.
  • Follow all state-level surcharge laws: several states still restrict or limit the practice, such as Colorado’s 2% cap. Additionally, your fee charge more than your costs.

Miss a step and you risk fines or a surprise visit from a card-brand secret shopper.

Why Surcharging Matters for Merchants

Margins are thin, and credit card fees can rise biannually. By adding a surcharge, you can offset processing costs, often 2-4%, without nudging loyal customers toward competitors with across-the-board price bumps.

Done right, a surcharge also:

  • Keeps advertised prices competitive for cash, cash-check, or debit card users.
  • Promotes transparency; customers see the real cost of their payment choice.
  • Reduces the temptation to hide fees inside higher sticker prices.

But you must ensure compliance. Apply the fee to a debit card and you could face chargebacks, network penalties, or even legal trouble. Education at checkout, whether verbal, printed, or digital, is non-negotiable for smooth adoption.

Key Benefits for ISVs Offering Surcharge Solutions

For software vendors, helping merchants implement a surcharge unlocks three wins:

  1. Merchant Value & Retention: Cutting transaction fees keeps stores profitable and sticky.
  2. Revenue & Differentiation: Offering a built-in, branded surcharge tool gives your platform a clear advantage over competitors who force merchants to recover fees manually or with clunky workarounds like cash-only policies.
  3. Built-In Protection: Auto debit detection–technology that automatically identifies if the card is credit and applies the surcharge, real-time rule updates, and on-screen disclosures let you promise compliance without forcing busy merchants to memorize every statute.

When margins improve, merchants grow. When merchants grow inside your ecosystem, so do you.

How MSG Payment Systems Powers Safe, Compliant Surcharging

Looking for turnkey rather than DIY? MSG Payment Systems delivers:

  • Auto-Calculation & Caps: The engine computes the exact fee, never exceeding cost or legal limits.
  • Instant Debit Card Detection: If the BIN is debit or prepaid, the payment technology blocks the surcharge automatically.
  • Signage & Receipt Tools: Ready-made templates tick every disclosure box, so clerks don’t improvise.
  • ISV-Friendly APIs: Drop-in modules add surcharging to POS, mobile, or e-commerce flows in days, not months.

With MSG you’re not just compliant, you’re supportive, protective, efficient, assured, and responsive, exactly how your merchants expect a payment partner to act.

Learn why forming the right payment partnerships is key for ISVs.

Implementation Checklist

  1. Partner with MSG – MSG will handle the setup for you. 
  2. Train Staff – Teach the “why” so every cashier can explain it in one sentence.
  3. Monitor & Review – Audit monthly to catch rule changes early.

Conclusion: Reduce Costs, Stay Compliant, Add Value

A compliant credit card surcharge program can reclaim thousands in annual fees without alienating customers or raising shelf prices. Merchants shore up margins; ISVs strengthen their product stickiness; consumers keep the freedom to choose.

Ready to regain control of rising card costs? Connect with MSG Payment Systems today and launch a surcharge solution that is transparent, automated, and rock-solid on compliance.

Share:

More Posts

Fleet Card Acceptance for Propane Merchants

Introduction: Why It Matters Propane merchants who ignore specialized payment programs could be leaving money on the table. A fleet card lets commercial drivers pay

ISV Guide to Split Funding for Merchants

Introduction Merchants today need faster, easier access to capital to keep their businesses running and growing. Managing cash flow can be challenging, especially when businesses

Fueling Savings: How Propane Merchants Can Reduce Credit Card Processing Fees

Introduction For propane merchants, every dollar saved has a direct impact on profitability. High credit card processing fees not only reduce margins but also constrain

Same Day Funding: Rapid Cash Access for Merchants

Introduction to Same Day Funding for Merchants Same day funding refers to the ability for merchants to receive the proceeds from their credit card sales

MSG Payment Systems
10555 New York Ave., Ste. 101,
Urbandale, Iowa 50322


1-888-697-8831


Contact Us

Linkedin Facebook

© 2024 MSG Payment Systems. MSG Payment Systems. All rights reserved. MSG Payment Systems is a registered ISO of Fifth Third Bank, N.A., Cincinnati, OH. All product names, logos, brands, trademarks and registered trademarks are property of their respective owners. Privacy Policy